Authors
Meir Simha Barneron, Yoram Rabin, Yaniv Vaki, Amit Pundik
Published in
Law and human behavior. Oct 29, 2026. Epub Oct 29, 2026.
Abstract
"Guilty" or "not guilty" is typically the choice that decision-makers face in criminal trials. However, Scotland and Israel stand out for their use of a third, intermediate, verdict (Scotland having only recently abolished its "not proven" option). In such verdicts, decision-makers may opt not to fully acquit the defendant-who nevertheless walks free, without criminal sanction. Rationally, the availability of intermediate verdicts should not affect the probability of conviction, since the legal question remains whether the evidence suffices to prove guilt "beyond-reasonable-doubt." If the number of verdict-alternatives does influence conviction rates, the decision making is distorted-an effect we term "N-verdict bias." We investigated the extent to which professional legal decision-makers are vulnerable to this bias.
We expected the N-verdict bias to arise among both professionals and nonprofessionals, but to be of lower magnitude among the former.
Seven studies were conducted (N = 1,934) on participants with varying levels of legal expertise: bar disciplinary-panel adjudicators, practicing lawyers, law students, and laypeople. In Studies 1-5, participants rendered a verdict on a fictitious murder case, under two- versus three-verdict conditions. Study 6 tested whether receiving instructions about the beyond-reasonable-doubt standard eliminated the bias. Study 7 ascertained the internal confidence-threshold participants deemed necessary for conviction under two- versus three-verdict conditions.
The N-verdict bias arose among laypeople, law students, and professionals: The availability of an intermediate verdict decreased the conviction rate. This bias was uninfluenced by legal expertise and was present even when participants were instructed to convict only if guilt were proven beyond-reasonable-doubt. The confidence-threshold required for conviction did not vary significantly between the two conditions.
Defendants are less likely to be convicted in a three-verdict system, making the number of verdict-alternatives another source of bias in legal decision making that legal expertise does not immunize against. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2026 APA, all rights reserved).
PMID:
42956240
Bibliographic data and abstract were imported from PubMed on 30 Oct 2026.
Read full publication at:
Please sign in
to see all details.
Advertisement
Stats
- Recommendations n/a n/a positive of 0 vote(s)
- Views 21
- Comments 0