Authors
Sabrina Ayoub-Charette, Laura Chiavaroli, Alexandra E Cowan-Pyle, Josh Erndt-Marino, Kelly A Higgins, Colby J Vorland, Caitlin D DeVore, Andrew W Keitt, Andrew W Brown
Published in
The Journal of nutrition. Pages 101932. Nov 06, 2026. Epub Nov 06, 2026.
Abstract
The practices of lumping together and splitting apart foods, nutrients, and diet patterns shape the interpretation of nutritional evidence and guidance.
To discuss the inherent complexity of 'lumping' and 'splitting' foods, nutrients, and diet patterns, we held an in-person colloquium in December 2024, where we utilized dialogue mapping to summarize the discussion in real-time. Knowledgeable early-career nutrition researchers explored the contexts for lumping and splitting with the goal of beginning a conversation in the scientific community on the topic.
Six themes emerged about lumping or splitting: definitions and history, population heterogeneity, consumer behavior, policy and public health messaging, frameworks for categorization, and measurement and methods. Participants identified lumping that persists on historical rather than scientific grounds, with circularity in policy in which guidelines are used to build adherence indices that are then used to evaluate those guidelines. The shifting protein categories across successive Dietary Guidelines for Americans Scientific Reports showed the same foods being lumped or split for different purposes. Measurement error and incomplete food composition data limit splitting, whereas life stage, physiology, and culture favored finer categories.
Participants emphasized that lumping and splitting are not inherently right or wrong, nor are they inherently a binary approach; rather, the appropriateness to lump or split depends on the purpose of the analysis, public health messaging, or evidence-informed policy decisions. Future work is needed to operationalize lumping and splitting decisions in the field of nutrition science, and to enhance transparency in the rationale of lumping and splitting decisions.
PMID:
42994694
Bibliographic data and abstract were imported from PubMed on 07 Nov 2026.
Read full publication at:
Please sign in
to see all details.
Advertisement
Stats
- Recommendations n/a n/a positive of 0 vote(s)
- Views 10
- Comments 0