Hiring in life sciences? Share your open positions with our professional community. Read more Close

Advertisement

Ask, don't assume: Editorial and Data Integrity Triage (EDIT), an editor's practice-based checklist for screening manuscripts at submission.

Created on 13 Nov 2026

Authors

Mamdooh Alzyood

Published in

The Journal of hospital infection. Nov 12, 2026. Epub Nov 12, 2026.

Abstract

As an editor, I regularly find problems in submitted manuscripts that need explaining before peer review can begin. A reference cannot be found, participant numbers in the abstract differ from those in the tables, or the methods do not explain the results. Most have an honest explanation, but some do not, and paper mills and text produced by artificial intelligence (AI) add to the pressure on editors. My message in this paper is simple. When something does not add up, editors should ask the authors a specific question before assuming anything, and they should judge the work itself and leave aside who wrote it. I describe Editorial and Data Integrity Triage (EDIT), a checklist I developed from my editorial work at the Journal of Hospital Infection and from academic integrity practice. EDIT has 20 checks in five domains covering reporting, methods and data, references, authorship and declarations, and submission files. Ten core checks can be applied to every submission and the others when they are relevant. Each finding leads to routine handling, a request for clarification or a pause for senior assessment. Writing style, a free email account, an incomplete author profile, the authors' country and unusually tidy data are not treated as evidence of a problem. A fictional example follows one submission from the first checks to an editorial decision, and I identify the checks that peer reviewers can use. EDIT reflects one editor's practice, and independent review and testing are needed before it is used routinely.

PMID:
43020277
Bibliographic data and abstract were imported from PubMed on 13 Nov 2026.

Read full publication at:
Please sign in to see all details.

Advertisement

Stats

  • Community rating n/a 0 votes
  • Reviewers' rating n/a 0 votes
  • Your rating

1-terrible, 9-excellent. How would you rate this publication? Sign in in to submit your rating.

  • Recommendations n/a n/a positive of 0 vote(s)
  • Views 9
  • Comments 0

Recommended by

  • No recommendations yet.

Post a comment

You need to be signed in to post comments. You can sign in here.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Advertisement