Authors
Pei-Yu Yang, Wenmay Rei, Yu-Chan Chiu, Rosetta Siew, Chuan-Yu Chen
Published in
The International journal on drug policy. Volume 159. Pages 105606. Nov 18, 2026. Epub Nov 18, 2026.
Abstract
Drug policy in many jurisdictions has shifted from punitive control toward health-oriented governance; however, how these reforms translate into frontline practice remains poorly understood, particularly for women whose care spans health, welfare, and criminal-legal systems. Taiwan provides an informative case following the 2018 transfer of community addiction services from the justice sector to the health sector. We examined how providers navigate competing institutional demands and their implications for women's care.
We conducted semi-structured interviews with 20 frontline providers across healthcare, criminal-legal, child protection, community addiction, and non-governmental services in Taiwan. Data were analyzed using abductive thematic analysis informed by institutional logics and structural vulnerability.
Three interrelated themes were identified. First, medicalization did not replace punitive governance but layered medical care onto existing criminal-legal control, leaving providers to balance support and surveillance. Second, motherhood became a key site of institutional power, with pregnancy, child custody, and parenting used to enforce treatment rules and judge a woman's fitness as a mother. Third, fragmented governance, including divided accountability, disconnected information systems, and resource constraints, limited coordination; in providers' accounts, women needing multiple services were left to navigate fragmented care.
Taiwan's experience suggests that transferring addiction services to the health sector does not necessarily transform frontline practices. Providers' accounts showed how broader institutional tensions took gendered forms through motherhood and child welfare involvement. Without stronger institutional accountability and cross-sector coordination, medicalization may relocate, rather than replace, punitive governance. These findings underscore the importance of institutional reform for gender-responsive drug policy.
PMID:
43050880
Bibliographic data and abstract were imported from PubMed on 19 Nov 2026.
Read full publication at:
Please sign in
to see all details.
Advertisement
Stats
- Recommendations n/a n/a positive of 0 vote(s)
- Views 7
- Comments 0